Platinum Blonde Nomads in Kerala – Online Maps

Having established that the paper maps are very limited I have been thinking about how to use free online mapping.

Google small Munnar

Google maps might seem an obvious choiceThe , they are usually adopted by cyclists to publish routes. As well as good (ish) route planning tools they contain a lot of detailed information, including details of sites and businesses added by users. At first glance the Google mapping of Kerala is much more comprehensive than the paper maps, showing a lot of minor roads and tracks and many small towns.

Another advantage of Google is that you can download “offline” copies of their maps for up to a month’s use when you don’t have easy access to the internet. That will be very useful as I can carry a copy on my cheap Android smartphone. Even though the phone will not be connected to a network in India, the combination of Google maps and the phone’s Global Positioning System (GPS)  will provide us with a way to find out where we are.

But you can’t beat a paper map and I felt I had to be able to print out an “Atlas” for the trip which is where it all became more interesting. Google maps are neither attractively presented nor very easy to read, especially when printed. So I started looking around for alternatives.

Microsoft’s Bing maps were an obvious choice since their UK mapping is really good, using much better original material than their competitors including Ordnance Survey maps. However in India, outside the cities, Bing is not much help as it only provides very minimal information, just a few main roads.

Open Streetmap is similar. I’m a big fan of the Open Streetmap project to build a free world map from the information collected by ordinary people, and in well-populated technically advanced areas, particularly in Europe, it provides a good level of detail. But in India it’s minimal.

Yahoo Maps does provide some benefits as an occasional alternative to Google (Incidentally that link I have provided is to the Yahoo UK maps site but the actual map is for the whole world). The advantages are that it shows more small towns than Google, in some areas at least, although not as many roads and some quite significant roads are missing. The main advantage however is good design for legibility and reading comfort. Here are some samples to show the comparison:

Yahoo Map of Munnar area

Yahoo map sample

Only the most important roads but very clearly shown, good clear type and outlined roads rather than just a coloured line. A few more small towns/villages than Google although, as usual, some of the locations are suspect. For example Baisonvally in the centre of the map sounds suspiciously like Bison Valley, which Google shows some way to the south.

Google Map of Munnar Area

Google map sample

As well as the Bison Valley confusion you may notice that the two maps have Pooppara in different locations and I’m pretty sure, from cyclists journals and blogs, that Google is correct. Google also has more roads but Yahoo is definitely easier to read.

Yahoo Map of Munnar Centre

Yahoo sample Munnar

Zooming in for some urban detail, Yahoo shows an extensive network of roads within the town (other towns are similar) but very little other information.

Google Map of Munnar Centre

Google sample Munnar

Google does not have the streets but it does have a lot more local information in street names and local points of interest. As you zoom in on Google you get a lot more of that information, a lot of it with clickable links.

So it’s clear that I need to use both but I think I’ll start with Yahoo for a printable map that I can annotate. I’ve started by screen-grabbing “tiles” of the Yahoo map to make my own map of the central section of Kerala as a giant .jpg image. I’ll probably cut and past sections from that into Powerpoint where I can add text and graphics and print it or export it as a .pdf

Incidentally, for both types of map I found that reducing brightness (from 50% to 35%) and increasing contrast (from 50% to 70%) make a huge difference to legibility when printed. Those numbers work in the Powerpoint “format picture” dialogue.

I’ll come back to this later as there are a number of aspects of route planning, route recording and using maps that need more thought.

<Previous: 3. Not so Grey?

4 Responses to “Platinum Blonde Nomads in Kerala – Online Maps”

  1. sizbut Says:

    For a recent tour to Cape Wrath, that cousin of on-line maps, Google street view, was an invaluable planning tool. It allowed us to spot the possible shops, pubs and cash machines whilst still several hundred miles away. Ironically the trip’s highlight was 11 miles of road that was not on street view.

  2. chrisrust Says:

    Yes I use Streetview a lot. I ‘surveyed’ a route across Paris with Streetview and in the end I didn’t need to refer to my printout of the route as I had learned it well. It was also good on the west side of Loch Awe where I needed to identify an unmarked track that led down to the lakeside cycle trail and saved us some steep hills. But I don’t think Streetview works in rural India.
    An alternative for some places is to search for tourist photos on Google Image. I worked out how to cycle out of Beijing airport that way.

  3. JdeP Says:

    You mention saving maps as PDFs: the Nexus 7 can display PDFs in wonderful clear, crispness.
    (Before I had the Nexus I spent some time experimenting — mainly fruitlessly — with saving maps for use on a Kindle).

  4. chrisrust Says:

    That’s right and the Nexus 7 is my current favourite gadget (you shot my fox as I was going to discuss travel gadgets in a future post). I save pdfs to Google Drive, mark them to be available offline on the Nexus and view them with the Acrobat App. I also have a pdf annotation app so I could add notes to the map during the journey, but scrawling on paper maps works well for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: